# Utterances and Blogdown

Making posts commentable using utteranc.es

While browsing the many sites I used as references to help get my website up and running with blogdown, I saw the cool Github-like comments section at the bottom of the posts. I was envious as it looked really cool! Disqus always put me off a bit so I figured I would just not have a comments section. Not that I expect much traffic. In any case, I added it to my to-do list for the site. Today, I tackle it 😎.

# Installation

The installation turned out to be quite easy. I followed Maëlle’s great post to get me started. She uses a different theme but due to tips in her comment section I managed to apply it to the Wowchemy/Academic theme this site uses. I took a slightly different route though, more on that later. It boiled down to these steps;

1. Install the utterances app to your repo. I chose to just install it on my site repo only. I missed this step initially while testing the result locally and therefore put it on top.

2. Create a label for comments as the utteranc.es bot is not able to do that itself. Emojis in labels possible 😄!

3. Fill in the utteranc.es configuration page and copy the script snippet at the end.

4. This is the part where I chose a different route. I copied the code from step 3 into layouts/partials/comments/utterances.html . ⚠️ Not in the underlying themes/ folder but in the root directory of my website. So create folders as necessary.

5. Changed the comments provider in the params.yaml 1 to provider: 'utterances' .

6. Tested locally using blogdown::serve_site() and left a test comment.

7. 🥳

## Step 4 - Why?

The comments mentioned placing a comments.html containing the configuration from step 3 in the layouts/partials/ directory in the root directory of your site. I noticed while exploring the theme folder that there was a subdirectory called comments/ which contained two .html files namely, commento.html and disqus.html . I recognized those from editing my config.yaml during initial setup of the site. The comments.html file contained the following code:

{{ $provider := trim (site.Params.comments.provider | lower) " " }} {{ if$provider }}
{{ $provider_tpl := printf "partials/comments/%s.html"$provider }}

...

{{ if $commentable_page }} <section id="comments"> {{ partial$provider_tpl . }}
</section>
{{ end }}
{{ end }}

So it seems that the template for the different comment providers is collected from the subdirectory. So I wondered if it would work to create a new provider by adding utterances.html to the subdirectory. 🚨 Spoiler it did 🥳!

I preferred this method as I found it a bit more elegant, by using functionality provided to me by the theme’s author. This also allows me to easily disable it by setting provider: '' in my config.yaml . For example, if it needs to be temporarily disabled, for whatever reason, or if I want to test a different provider in the future. Of course deleting comments.html is real easy. Many ways lead to Rome.

# Conclusion

Thanks to many to helpful comments in Maëlle’s blog I was able to add comments to my website with utteranc.es. I also learned a bit about how the theme I use and Hugo work. I am happy with the result.

1. Found in config/_default/params.yaml . Note that I used blogdown::new_site() to install the theme and it converted the .toml to .yaml .↩︎

😄